Eomer
Junior Member
Planes rock.
Posts: 548
|
Post by Eomer on Nov 8, 2007 8:20:32 GMT
I was thinking, what would happen if one of the heroes dies. So, do you think it would change the outcome if...
Eomer and his men were just riding away from talking with Aragorn and 2 others, and they heard wild wargs approaching.
Sharku had just been sent out on a patrol. And in the distance he saw horses. Rohan and Wargs engage.
Aragorn and company hear fighting in the distance and drop what they're doing and go to battle.
Now, it would definitely change the outcome if Aragorn died, but, what would happen if Eomer or the others died.
Tell me what you think. I was thinking I could change this into a scenario.
|
|
Red Corsairs
Junior Member
Total LOTR 28th member!
Posts: 838
|
Post by Red Corsairs on Nov 8, 2007 18:06:49 GMT
well eomer sure helped majorly in BotPF when he took out the mumakil, but he also helped gather the rohirrim for BoHD and BotPF
|
|
|
Post by High Elven Lord on Nov 9, 2007 0:44:05 GMT
Well, theoretically, alot of things could have happened with the loss of Eomer. The Defense of the Caves? If I re-call correctly Eomer and Gimli along with a handful of warriors fell back to the caves, what happens if the caves are lost? Also, on the battle near the causeway, would Aragorn have gone to face the men with anyone else? Would the gates have fallen sooner? Brings up alot of questions.
|
|
Eomer
Junior Member
Planes rock.
Posts: 548
|
Post by Eomer on Nov 16, 2007 5:49:33 GMT
If Eomers cavalry died in this battle, Helms Deep would have been lost. But if he died and Helms Deep was saved it wouldn't of changed the Battle of Pellenor Fields because he only got two Mumaks.(Did he?) And the dead would have killed those two mumaks anyway. And another question is, what would've happened if either Gimli or Legolas or both had died. Would Aragorn have made it through the paths of the dead.
|
|
Jadmoroth
Junior Member
Jadmoroth, The Elven Jedi
Posts: 566
|
Post by Jadmoroth on Nov 16, 2007 7:43:06 GMT
Yeah Aragorn would have made it, they didn't make too much of a difference anyway.
|
|
|
Post by Warlord of Morgul on Nov 16, 2007 18:51:49 GMT
[glow=green,2,300]Of course, if Eomer died, Theoden would most likely go mad through grief because of the loss of both his male heirs. That would have most likely led to him doing something rash like taking on Saruman's armies in open battle as Gandalf suggested. I reckon that if one of the pair dies (Legolas/Gimli) it would be such a tragedy that it's box's office sales will hit rock bottom and the book wouldn't sell. The other companion would become quieter. If someone rewrote the book or remade the movie in which both of them die then they would most likely be put to death by lethal injection, and Middle Earth would never be the same again. [/glow]
|
|
|
Post by bringerofchaos on Nov 19, 2007 20:37:07 GMT
i think if eomer died aragorn would comit suic... he always liked him a lot deep down...
|
|
Red Corsairs
Junior Member
Total LOTR 28th member!
Posts: 838
|
Post by Red Corsairs on Nov 21, 2007 9:52:58 GMT
i think WoM has a very good point there, well explained aswell ;D
|
|
Ryuzaki
Rookie
Do ents get morning wood?
Posts: 183
|
Post by Ryuzaki on Jan 2, 2008 21:49:43 GMT
which brings another point, if eomer died helms deep may have been lost meaning that legy gimly and aragorn would have died, meaning that noone would get the army of the dead, meaning minas tirith would be lost, meaning that frodo and Sam wouldn't have gotten to mount doom, meaning Sauron would take the ring, meaning that the world would end. okay durburz take a breath in... out... in... out... so eomer was really important
|
|
Red Corsairs
Junior Member
Total LOTR 28th member!
Posts: 838
|
Post by Red Corsairs on Jan 2, 2008 22:01:20 GMT
Ok another very good point and well explained durburz. It's amazing just how much losing one person could have done to the story/film. But please durburz restrain yourself from doing 1 post straight after another like that again. Its ok, we have probably all done it once, and i know i have before here but i have learnt its not a good idea and is called spamming . So through all of the excitement of being a new member here try to remember that .
|
|
Eomer
Junior Member
Planes rock.
Posts: 548
|
Post by Eomer on Jan 2, 2008 22:11:56 GMT
Yeah, click modify and then you can add another that you migh've forgotten to say. But yeah, I was important wasn't I.
|
|
Red Corsairs
Junior Member
Total LOTR 28th member!
Posts: 838
|
Post by Red Corsairs on Jan 2, 2008 22:17:37 GMT
or you can just delete that post and then edit it into your other post. Just some info for you in the future durburz . And of course for any other people who might have done this before
|
|
Ryuzaki
Rookie
Do ents get morning wood?
Posts: 183
|
Post by Ryuzaki on Jan 2, 2008 23:31:28 GMT
or you can just delete that post and then edit it into your other post. Just some info for you in the future durburz . And of course for any other people who might have done this before that is what i did if you look.
|
|